American Airlines is trying hard to please, but
loyalists are skeptical
Pat Caputo
My wake-up call came at 4:45 a.m., but I wasn't in a hotel. American
Airlines was on the line telling me I was being rerouted through Chicago
O'Hare to Fort Lauderdale, Fla. My flight to Dallas/Fort Worth was delayed
and I would never make my connection without sprinting at Mach II through
the Texas megaport.
That was thoughtful - I thought. The bad news: I was flying full-fare coach
but was upgraded to first class on every leg. Now the re-rerouting put me in
economy out of Chicago. I'd also arrive 20 minutes later going through the
Windy City, said the apologetic voice on the other end of the phone. It
could be worse.
Breezing past the skycap at San Francisco, where American stiffs you $2 a
bag to check in, the ticket counter was fully staffed but no one was
waiting. I went through security in a record six or seven minutes.
American had a 767 on the flight to Chicago with its new reclining
first-class seat. The so-called privacy "suites" are on the 777 only at this
time. Still, these seats are the two-tray tables with extra storage.
With the Big Six airlines cutting back on everything, including first-class
amenities, it was surprising to receive a hot egg, sausage and pineapple
quesadilla breakfast with berries and a bagel. The flight attendants were
smiling and patient. It was a pleasant surprise.
Nevertheless, my seatmate, a nurse who lives in Chicago and is gold level on
American's AAdvantage program, isn't impressed. She didn't want her name
used, but said she only gets an upgrade when she is flying with her husband
who is platinum level.
"On recent overnight international flights, to London and Paris, the flight
attendants were mostly grumpy and you feel like a nuisance asking for
anything," she added.
On the Chicago to Fort Lauderdale leg, we left O'Hare 30 minutes late and a
paper goods saleswoman, who makes the flight weekly and is executive
platinum in the frequent flyer program, wasn't surprised.
"Until the last three or four months, almost every Fort Lauderdale flight
was late and you'd get 'attitude' from the flight attendants," said the
saleswoman who also wanted to remain anonymous."
However, she conceded the "on-time rate on this flight has improved, but the
biggest improvement has been the cabin crew's much friendlier attitude." Her
priorities from an airline: on-time departures and arrivals followed by
friendly service.
Even in coach, where the $5 turkey wrap was tasty, I found the flight
attendants accommodating and responsive.
American's veracity was called into question by two loyal passengers. The
paper saleswoman said she didn't receive the heads-up phone call.
"I went all the way through security to discover the flight was canceled and
blamed on weather. I was rescheduled to 6 a.m. the next morning, got up at
3:30 a.m. to get to the airport by 5 a.m., and it was delayed until 8 a.m.
Again, no phone call. Also, when it's a weather delay, you don't get a hotel
voucher."
She's absolutely convinced that American's delays are not related to
weather, instead due to crew availability.
On the Fort Lauderdale to Dallas/Fort Worth flight, Walter Rogers, president
of WDR Consulting in Fort Worth told me he also thinks American's in-flight
service "improved, but they are consistently late and you miss appointments
because of it; it backs up the rest of your day."
Rogers said as an executive platinum frequent flyer, "most of the time I get
upgraded."
His No. 2 gripe with American is lack of flight attendant friendliness.
"I understand these people are getting hammered but don't take it out on
me."
Again, on four legs, I didn't detect any attitude.
Technical consultant Nikki Narang switched from American, where he was
AAdvantage platinum to United, because he commutes weekly from San Jose,
Calif., to Hartford, Conn., for four days, not because he was dissatisfied
with American's service.
"United is the new cattle car - people cut in front of you, elbow you aside.
Plus, they don't tell the truth."
United told Narang his flight was grounded because of foul weather in
Hartford. He called Southwest.
"They told me 'we don't show weather. All of our flights from Hartford are
taking off on time.'"
He booked it. Even with two stops, he said he beat the United flight time
"because Southwest turns around so fast."
Chris Barnett writes on business travel strategies that save time, money and
hassle.